thumbnailcreator
Open studio

GPT Image 2 vs
Nano Banana Pro
for YouTube thumbnails

Same prompts. Six real outputs. Compare headline placement, room for a title, and product labels before choosing your next model.

Generated · Reviewed
One output per model per brief · visual observations, no CTR test

Start with the layout you need

Both models spelled all requested labels correctly in these six saved outputs. Layout is the useful difference to inspect: compare headline placement, room for a title and extra elements before choosing which to run on your brief.

Try the headline prompt with both models

$0.56 for one of each at current standard prices (USD).
Opens an editable brief with these two models. New accounts buy a $10 credit pack to generate.

01 · Make room for the headline

The same brief asked for a cracked phone and the exact words “DON’T BUY THIS.” Both images spell the line; their layouts leave different editing work.

GPT Image 2

A man holding a cracked phone on the left, with the outlined yellow headline DON'T BUY THIS on the right against red.
The man and cracked phone sit left of the outlined yellow headline. The lettering has a separate area on the right.
Open full image

Nano Banana Pro

The outlined yellow headline DON'T BUY THIS spans the top above a man and cracked phone against red.
The outlined yellow headline runs across the top. The hand and phone area is crowded and deserves a closer look.
Open full image

Where should your headline sit? The GPT Image 2 sample separates the presenter and headline left to right; the Nano Banana Pro sample uses a top headline. Choose the arrangement your video needs and name it in your own prompt. Inspect the hands and phone at full size before using either output.

Read the exact prompt

YouTube thumbnail: shocked man holding a cracked smartphone, huge bold yellow text "DON'T BUY THIS" with a black outline, bright red background, high contrast

02 · Leave a place for your title

The portrait brief requested a laughing woman on a rainy Tokyo street and empty space on the left. No text was requested.

GPT Image 2

A laughing woman on the right of a rainy neon-lit street, with continuous dark street scenery to her left.
The laughing face is right of a continuous dark street scene. The left side stays part of the same scene.
Open full image

Nano Banana Pro

A laughing woman and umbrella on the right, with a separate blurred vertical strip along the left edge.
The woman and umbrella sit on the right. A visibly separate blurred strip reserves space along the left edge.
Open full image

What counts as room for a title? A dark part of a scene and a separate blank strip give a title different backgrounds. Place your actual words over the area you intend to use, then check the result at a small preview size. Neither sample proves how the model will compose a different portrait.

Read the exact prompt

YouTube thumbnail: close-up of a woman laughing on a rainy Tokyo street at night, neon reflections, cinematic lighting, empty space on the left for a title, no text

03 · Compare two products

The coffee brief requested a $5 paper cup on the left and a $50 porcelain cup on the right, with bold white prices.

GPT Image 2

A paper coffee cup labeled $5 beside a porcelain cup labeled $50, with an added VS badge in the center.
The prices appear above the two cups. An unrequested VS badge sits between them.
Open full image

Nano Banana Pro

Hands hold a paper cup and a porcelain cup, with $5 and $50 over the cups in a split-screen composition.
The prices appear over the cups. Unrequested hands hold both cups, adding another detail to inspect.
Open full image

Did the model add anything you did not ask for? Both samples keep the requested $5 and $50 labels. GPT Image 2 adds a VS badge; Nano Banana Pro adds hands. If the image should show only two products, explicitly exclude badges and hands, then inspect the new result for extra details.

Read the exact prompt

YouTube thumbnail: split-screen comparison, a paper cup of coffee on the left labeled "$5" and a luxury porcelain cup on the right labeled "$50", clean studio lighting, bold white numbers

What this comparison can tell you

These six images come from the shared-prompt run on : one output per model per prompt, at 16:9, without reference images or reruns. The saved JPEGs are shown here with a fresh visual review dated . The full-image links open the stored artifacts.

This is a small visual sample. Different prompts and repeated runs can change the result. There was no viewer experiment, click-through-rate measurement or statistical quality ranking. These images do not show how a later model version would perform.

Recorded times from the original run
  • GPT Image 2: bold headline text 69s; photoreal face 77s; side-by-side comparison 67s.
  • Nano Banana Pro: bold headline text 21s; photoreal face 25s; side-by-side comparison 21s.

These are elapsed times for single historical runs, including provider wait time. They are not a current speed benchmark or a delivery guarantee.

Current studio prices

GPT Image 2
$0.26 / image
Nano Banana Pro
$0.30 / image

Current standard prices in USD from the studio model registry, separate from the historical image test. Only successful images are charged. New accounts buy a $10 credit pack; credits do not expire.

See all nine tested models →

Check the final thumbnail at a glance

Run one real video brief through both models. Check the generated text, hands and objects at full size, then compare the thumbnail at 160 pixels wide. Keep the output that fits your intended composition; these six examples do not establish an overall winner.

Open the free thumbnail preview →